The Campus That Never Was

 

The best-laid plans for

Swarthmore's campus weren't

always realized, but good

sense and good ideas

have prevailed over time.

 

Text by Elizabeth Weber '98

Captions by Margaret Helfand '69

 

 

 

(Right) The fanciful outdoor theater proposed by architect E.L. Tilton would have been a charming structure set in a public park but an odd addition to the Swarthmore campus. The date of the plan is unknown, but we can surmise that it was one of the ideas presented at the time the Scott Amphitheater was built by Thomas B. McCabe as a memorial to his friend Arthur Hoyt Scott. And we can be thankful that Quaker traditions of simplicity and economy eventually held sway. The College inherited an inspiring example of a successful marriage of nature and human intervention.



Editor's Note: With the completion last year of the College's $30 million North Campus Project, which included the building of Kohlberg Hall and the complete renovation of Trotter, major construction projects have halted on campus.

But not for long.

A comprehensive long-range planning effort currently under way will lead to a new set of goals and priorities for the next century that will doubtless include further renovations and building projects.

A subcommittee of the College Planning Committee (CPC) has examined the College's physical plant. Its preliminary report, presented to the CPC last spring, identified five potential areas of improvement: renovation of and addition to the DuPont Science Building, renovation of Parrish Hall, a new residence hall, renovation of and addition to McCabe library, and a new facility for student activities.

Swarthmore's current position of academic and financial strength allows for measured and thoughtful planning, with the expectation that the College's future needs will be met. But it wasn't always so, as College history buff Elizabeth Weber '98 learned during many hours of research in the Friends Historical Library. We also asked architect Margaret Helfand '69 to contribute her professional opinion of the "the campus that never was."

In 1930 it was clear that Swarthmore was on the verge of a building boom. The size of the student body had doubled since the turn of the century, to nearly 700. The dining room could not hold the ever-increasing number of students; the library was in desperate need of more space; the men's and women's gymnasiums needed replacing; the observatory was situated far too close to the new Clothier Memorial Hall; Worth Hall had been designed as half a quadrangle, which would surely someday be completed; and funds had already been donated for the Edward Martin Biological Laboratory.

With so many projects anticipated, President Frank Aydelotte presented two master plans for the long-term development of the campus to the Board of Managers, so that new buildings would be placed in an aesthetically pleasing way and underground utilities could be located efficiently.

But Aydelotte could not foresee the extent of the Great Depression. The Lamb-Miller Field House opened in 1934 and Martin Biological Laboratory in 1937, but fund-raising campaigns of the scale needed to complete the plan had become unrealistic. The money that had been donated already for the relocation of the observatory was used instead to improve the existing facility and to renovate space for the departments of Mathematics and Psychology. A temporary addition was built behind the library. The Swarthmore Preparatory School folded during the Depression, and the College eventually bought the Prep's buildings, renaming three of them Palmer, Pittenger, and Roberts halls, easing the space shortage.

World War II further delayed completion of the master plan. Incomes rose, but building materials were needed for the war effort. The Board of Managers approved the expansion of Beardsley Hall in 1943, but the local War Planning Board vetoed the project, and so Beardsley was not enlarged to its present size until after the end of the war. Plans for an art deco-style North Campus Project lay dormant.

At the end of the war, planning began again in earnest. With some students sleeping in the gym, the need for a new dormitory was obvious. A larger library and a new science building were also high priorities. The Board of Managers believed that with higher income taxes, wealthy individuals who could donate entire buildings would become increasingly scarce; however, with incomes rising at the end of the war, they decided that a general fund-raising campaign should begin as soon as possible.

But the designs drawn in 1946 would never appear on Swarthmore's campus. Swarthmore leased and then purchased the Mary Lyon School buildings, again easing the housing shortage without constructing a new dormitory. Unexpected inflation eroded the value of the funds that had been raised, and building costs did not fall back to their prewar levels. Faculty salaries began to rise again after a 15-year freeze, further reducing the funds available for buildings.

Eventually all three of the buildings proposed in 1946 were built, but in the intervening years, their appearances changed beyond recognition. The women's dormitory, which completed the Worth quadrangle, became Willets, opening in 1959. The science hall north of Parrish became the DuPont Science Building, which opened in 1960. And the library on the east side of Parrish was McCabe, finished in 1968.

Since 1946 there appear to be almost no designs drawn for buildings that were never constructed. In part this is because the College had selected Vincent Kling as College architect by 1957 and saw no need to solicit alternative designs. Kling designed DuPont, Sharples, McCabe, Dana, and Hallowell. And in recent years, buildings haven't been designed at Swarthmore until the funds for their completion have been committed.

 

Elizabeth Weber '98 majored in economics and is working at the Census Bureau in Washington, D.C. Her article "Swarthmore and the NSA" appeared in the September 1997 Bulletin. She gratefully acknowledges the assistance of Mary Ellen Grafflin Chijioke '67, curator of the Friends Historical Library.

Margaret Helfand '69 finished her undergraduate education with a degree in architecture at UC-Berkeley. She is the principal of Margaret Helfand Architects in New York, lead architects and planners for the recently completed North Campus Project, including the design of Kohlberg Hall and renovations of Trotter Hall.

Proposed designs for campus buildings.

Martin Hall

Library


ALUMNI DIGEST / BOOKS BY ALUMNI / COLLECTION / EDITOR'S NOTE / FEATURES / LETTERS /

OUR BACK PAGES / POSTINGS / PROFILES / ARCHIVE / TALK BACK

Bulletin Home Page